The Pickled Herring Menu

The Pickled Herring in Englishtown, NJ, offers a soulful dive into classic kosher deli flavors with a menu that celebrates tradition and bold taste. Highlighted by their Overstuffed Pastrami Corned Beef Sandwich and the iconic Classic Reuben, each bite feels generous and deeply satisfying. The Pickled Herring in Cream Sauce stands out—a perfect balance of sweet, sour, and crunchy onions that embody authentic deli charm. Signature dishes like the Knishwich and Hot Corned Beef Sandwich add variety while keeping the heartiness intact. For those seeking comforting sides, the crispy Onion Rings and homemade Fries deliver exactly that. The menu also surprises with items like Stuffed Capons with Wild Rice and the Smoked Fish Platter for Two, showcasing rich textures and layered flavors. Customer praises reflect not just the food’s quality, but also the warm, attentive service creating memorable dining experiences. At The Pickled Herring, every dish is crafted with care, making it a must-visit for deli aficionados craving tradition fused with fresh enthusiasm.